With all of the changes to the patent system arising from
the decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court and the Court of Appeals for the Federal
Circuit, it’s helpful to go back to basics and to contemplate the fundamentals
of patent law in view of these decisions.
Below, we answer some frequently asked questions about
patents. This summary is provided for informational purposes only, and does not
constitute legal advice. Any specific question about patent law should be
directed to an attorney in our Patent Practice Group.
What is a patent?
A patent can be a very valuable asset for a business selling a novel product or using a novel process. A patent is a right, granted by the government, to exclude others from making, using or selling within the government’s jurisdiction the invention as claimed.
Patents are intended to promote innovation and the exchange of ideas. The granting of a patent is traditionally considered an exchange between the applicant and the government: the applicant permits the invention to be disclosed to the public (and pays a variety of fees) and in return the government grants the applicant a monopoly to practice the invention as claimed in the patent document. But of course it’s not that simple, as the invention and the patent application must meet all of the government’s requirements.
Having the right to exclude others from making and using or selling your invention can be a very powerful tool for the success of your business. At Sunstein, our goal is to allow the client to maximize the leverage afforded by patents and other intellectual property.
A patent can be a very valuable asset for a business selling a novel product or using a novel process. A patent is a right, granted by the government, to exclude others from making, using or selling within the government’s jurisdiction the invention as claimed.
Patents are intended to promote innovation and the exchange of ideas. The granting of a patent is traditionally considered an exchange between the applicant and the government: the applicant permits the invention to be disclosed to the public (and pays a variety of fees) and in return the government grants the applicant a monopoly to practice the invention as claimed in the patent document. But of course it’s not that simple, as the invention and the patent application must meet all of the government’s requirements.
Having the right to exclude others from making and using or selling your invention can be a very powerful tool for the success of your business. At Sunstein, our goal is to allow the client to maximize the leverage afforded by patents and other intellectual property.
What does a patent look like?
A patent is a document that describes the invention protected by the patent and sets forth in the claims the scope of the invention. To view a typical patent,
click here (PDF: 183KB). This patent was prosecuted by Sunstein. It, and other patents, can be found on the website of the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
Why are patents important?
If someone else has or obtains a patent that covers your product or process, you (i) may be enjoined from making, using and selling the product or process; and (ii) may be subject to significant monetary damages—even if you did no copying and even if you did not know about the patent. In certain cases, the damages may be doubled or trebled and attorney fees granted.
One of the services provided by Sunstein is to conduct searches of issued patents to determine the degree of risk our clients undertake in introducing new products or in continuing to sell a product accused of infringement. Often, we will suggest design modifications for a product to minimize the risk of a successful patent infringement suit against our clients. Sunstein prepares clearance opinions to address such issues, and we pay particular attention to how such opinions may be used by a defendant in patent litigation to advance its case, as well as to reduce the likelihood of multiple damages and the award of attorney fees.
If you can obtain a patent, you may be able to (i) prevent others from practicing the invention (including even those who independently develop their own product, as well as copycats); (ii) obtain license fees from others who wish to practice the invention; and (iii) use it as a marketing tool. At Sunstein, we view the obtaining of a patent not as an end, but as a means to achieving our clients’ goals, whether it is giving our clients a business advantage over competitors or producing an additional income stream for our clients.
Filing for a patent early (and keeping good records of the invention’s development) puts you in a better position vis-à-vis other inventors. Thus, it is almost always preferable for the patent attorneys to consult with the inventors early on in the development process, rather than waiting for the development of the product to be completed.
The fact that a person obtains a patent for an invention does NOT necessarily mean that the invention can be practiced without infringing someone else’s patent. The Patent and Trademark Office determines whether an invention is new enough to be entitled to a patent, but not whether a device, such as that described in a patent application, infringes anyone else’s patent. A typical example is when someone obtains a patent for an improvement on someone else’s patent: Until the earlier patent expires, a license may be required to practice the later invention. The earlier patent is therefore called a blocking patent. Like any other patent, a blocking patent may be invalidated if sufficient proof of unpatentability is shown during litigation. In some cases, however, the fact that a person obtains a patent for an invention is evidence that the product incorporating that later invention does not infringe an earlier patent cited during the prosecution of the later patent in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Having a patent portfolio may permit you to enter into cross-licensing arrangements with other companies that have patents on valuable related technology.
Building a patent portfolio can also increase the value of your company in the eyes of potential investors or buyers. A patent is an important piece of property, and may enable a company to obtain capital when it would otherwise be insolvent. Investors, of course, would like to invest in a company that has a product that is in demand, but has no competition. Investors also do not want to invest in a company that has made or will make significant expenditures in research, only to have the product “knocked off” by a low-cost producer that was able to avoid the research costs simply by copying.
On the other hand, if you are a potential investor or licensee, the value of a patent must not be overestimated. Simply because a company has a patent does not mean that the company is valuable—the patent may be narrow (thereby allowing plenty of competition), there may be no demand for the product covered by the patent, or the company’s product might be of poor quality. Patents by themselves do not necessarily result in royalty streams. The invention or the products incorporating the invention still have to be marketed—to customers, licensees or assignees—in order to make money. Frequently, for individual inventors, obtaining the patent is the easy part; it’s the money-making part that’s difficult. Also, a patent is NOT a seal of approval from the U.S. government. If one looks through the weekly Official Gazette published by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, one will find plenty of inventions that are not practical and that will not make any money.
These issues should be addressed whenever one is considering a technology transfer. At Sunstein, we feel it is critical to discuss fully such practical aspects of an invention with our clients and to appreciate the business and technical context of an invention, in order to advise our clients on a technology transfer issue. (More)
A patent is a document that describes the invention protected by the patent and sets forth in the claims the scope of the invention. To view a typical patent,
click here (PDF: 183KB). This patent was prosecuted by Sunstein. It, and other patents, can be found on the website of the United States Patent and Trademark Office.If someone else has or obtains a patent that covers your product or process, you (i) may be enjoined from making, using and selling the product or process; and (ii) may be subject to significant monetary damages—even if you did no copying and even if you did not know about the patent. In certain cases, the damages may be doubled or trebled and attorney fees granted.
One of the services provided by Sunstein is to conduct searches of issued patents to determine the degree of risk our clients undertake in introducing new products or in continuing to sell a product accused of infringement. Often, we will suggest design modifications for a product to minimize the risk of a successful patent infringement suit against our clients. Sunstein prepares clearance opinions to address such issues, and we pay particular attention to how such opinions may be used by a defendant in patent litigation to advance its case, as well as to reduce the likelihood of multiple damages and the award of attorney fees.
If you can obtain a patent, you may be able to (i) prevent others from practicing the invention (including even those who independently develop their own product, as well as copycats); (ii) obtain license fees from others who wish to practice the invention; and (iii) use it as a marketing tool. At Sunstein, we view the obtaining of a patent not as an end, but as a means to achieving our clients’ goals, whether it is giving our clients a business advantage over competitors or producing an additional income stream for our clients.
Filing for a patent early (and keeping good records of the invention’s development) puts you in a better position vis-à-vis other inventors. Thus, it is almost always preferable for the patent attorneys to consult with the inventors early on in the development process, rather than waiting for the development of the product to be completed.
The fact that a person obtains a patent for an invention does NOT necessarily mean that the invention can be practiced without infringing someone else’s patent. The Patent and Trademark Office determines whether an invention is new enough to be entitled to a patent, but not whether a device, such as that described in a patent application, infringes anyone else’s patent. A typical example is when someone obtains a patent for an improvement on someone else’s patent: Until the earlier patent expires, a license may be required to practice the later invention. The earlier patent is therefore called a blocking patent. Like any other patent, a blocking patent may be invalidated if sufficient proof of unpatentability is shown during litigation. In some cases, however, the fact that a person obtains a patent for an invention is evidence that the product incorporating that later invention does not infringe an earlier patent cited during the prosecution of the later patent in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
Having a patent portfolio may permit you to enter into cross-licensing arrangements with other companies that have patents on valuable related technology.
Building a patent portfolio can also increase the value of your company in the eyes of potential investors or buyers. A patent is an important piece of property, and may enable a company to obtain capital when it would otherwise be insolvent. Investors, of course, would like to invest in a company that has a product that is in demand, but has no competition. Investors also do not want to invest in a company that has made or will make significant expenditures in research, only to have the product “knocked off” by a low-cost producer that was able to avoid the research costs simply by copying.
On the other hand, if you are a potential investor or licensee, the value of a patent must not be overestimated. Simply because a company has a patent does not mean that the company is valuable—the patent may be narrow (thereby allowing plenty of competition), there may be no demand for the product covered by the patent, or the company’s product might be of poor quality. Patents by themselves do not necessarily result in royalty streams. The invention or the products incorporating the invention still have to be marketed—to customers, licensees or assignees—in order to make money. Frequently, for individual inventors, obtaining the patent is the easy part; it’s the money-making part that’s difficult. Also, a patent is NOT a seal of approval from the U.S. government. If one looks through the weekly Official Gazette published by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, one will find plenty of inventions that are not practical and that will not make any money.
These issues should be addressed whenever one is considering a technology transfer. At Sunstein, we feel it is critical to discuss fully such practical aspects of an invention with our clients and to appreciate the business and technical context of an invention, in order to advise our clients on a technology transfer issue. (More)
No comments:
Post a Comment